Your health and well-being are our top priority…

facebook.png twitter.png linkedin.png pinterest.png youtube.png Instagram.png

Aronoff's Point Of View: CMS rating system is flawed

Category List

Tag List

Tuition reimbursement (3)
Renal Center of Port Arthur (1)
RASKAL award (3)
NKF (2)
Pinnacle award (1)
Interview (1)
Denton police department (1)
immunization (2)
Arthritis Foundation (2)
home dialysis (1)
Renal Center of Bayonne (1)
flu vaccine (3)
Renal Center of Trenton (1)
Kidney Life Dialysis Center (1)
Tracy Moore (1)
DaVita Healthcare partners (1)
telehealth services (1)
Accel Rehab hospital (1)
travel (1)
QIRN3 (1)
Annual Dialysis Conference (1)
Children's Hospital (1)
rheumatology (1)
dogs (1)
Excellence award (1)
Mary Bowles (1)
halitosis (1)
Southlake Infusion (1)
Year in Review (5)
Kidney walk (1)
Multiple Sclerosis Society (1)
Fitibt (1)
Dr. Stuart Kassan (1)
Officer Orlando HInajosa (1)
The Hills (1)
nephron (1)
plasmapheresis (1)
Internship (3)
home hemodialysis (1)
Fitbit (1)
retirement (1)
flu shot (4)
RVMLife (1)
Costa Vida (1)
40th anniversary (1)
Frosty the Snowman (1)
NKF walk (2)
RV TLC (1)
kidney disease exercise (1)
Renal Center of Succasunna (1)
patient newsletter (3)
dialysis (2)
Certified Registered Nurse Infusion (1)
Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (1)
Lobby Day (1)
Bone and Joint Expo (1)
Take Your Dog to Work Day (1)
Best Place to Work (3)
construction (2)
North Denton (1)
World Kidney Month (4)
Michelle Weinraub (1)
NRAA (2)
Renal Adventures (2)
RVCare (4)
Carrollton (1)
North Texas Acute (1)
New Jersey (6)
American Society of Nephrology (1)
Texas Renal Ventures (2)
oral hygiene (1)
Authentidate (2)
American College of Rheumatology (1)
American Diabetes Association (1)
acute dialysis (1)
Renal Center of Carrollton (1)
Employee Appreciation (1)
recipe (2)
Bonfils blood donation (2)
National Kidney Month (2)
Social Worker (1)
dialysis patient exercise (1)
Renal Center of Plano (2)
#GoRed (2)
Patient Satisfaction Survey (1)
World Kidney Day (7)
Renal Center of Hamilton (3)
the Action Center (1)
acquisition (1)
New Orleans (1)
Spirit Award (1)
permanent access (1)
Infusion nurse (2)
Fire Prevention Week (1)
World Health Day (1)
Javier Rodriguez (1)
exercise (1)
Renal Center of Beaumont (1)
Intern (3)
Nephrology News (4)
Go Red for Women (5)
Pioneer award (1)
Human Resources (1)
Do's and Don'ts when interviewing (1)
MPP Infusion (10)
CRNI (1)
cupcake (1)
Plano (1)
Savor the Flavor of Eating Right (1)
new dialysis facility (1)
Renal Center of North Denton (1)
Orange, TX (1)
dialysis center (1)
Diane McGinnis (1)
Pinterest (1)
West Virginia (1)
graduates (1)
bubble soccer (1)
video (1)
Blizzard 2016 (1)
National Nutrition Month (1)
Elanderia Rowe (1)
wrestling (1)
pot de creme (1)
Port Arthur (1)
RV Wellness (4)
Redesign American Flag (1)
Renal Center of Morristown (1)
JCAHO accreditation (1)
meningioma (1)
remote patient monitoring (2)
Mother's Day (1)
Avalon at Edgewater (1)
Renal Center of Passaic (1)
Infusion Center of Denver (4)
10th anniversary (3)
miss dialysis (2)
CMS rating system (3)
dental care (1)
Stroke (2)
Digna Gutierrez (1)
Southlake, TX (1)
Council of Nephrology Social Workers (1)
Renal Center of Somerville (3)
Glass of water (1)
Z Constructors (1)
Spring Clinical Meeting (1)
Citizenship Day (3)
Infusion (6)
Saint Barnabas Medical Center (1)
RV Quality Program (3)
Dum Dums (1)
Toledo Bend Reservoir (1)
BioMed (1)
traveling on dialysis (1)
Flower Mound (2)
New Jerse (1)
RV Difference (8)
Naveena Redd (2)
Five Star rating (1)
Nederland (1)
ANNA (1)
Informative Infuser (1)
Dr. Aronoff (3)
open house (2)
National MS Society (1)
Rugged Maniac (1)
State Legislature (1)
acute nurse (1)
American Nephrology Nurses' Association (1)
cookbook (2)
Walk to Cure Arthritis (1)
DaVita (2)
Kidney cookbook (1)
CMS (2)
Renal Center of Orange (1)
New York Yankees (1)
American Heart Association (6)
RV KidneyCARE (2)
Positively Protein (3)
ANNA conference (1)
peritoneal dialysis (3)
Southeast flooding (1)
Choose My Plate (1)
smoke alarm (1)
Dallas (1)
Naveena Reddy (1)
Winter Storm Jonas (1)
gum disease (1)
apheresis (1)
Dr. Parker (1)
Orange (1)
RVM Kidney Care (1)
Paulding Phelps Award (1)
dietitian (1)
Protein (2)
Kidney Week (1)
back to school (1)
Home Kidney Care (2)
National Kidney Foundation (5)
Kindergarten (1)
Dr. George Aronoff (4)
dialysis treatment (2)
work anniversary (1)
Heart Disease (2)

Tag Cloud

Renal Center of PassaicDaVitaDigna GutierrezNew OrleansRenal Center of BeaumontDaVita Healthcare partnersExcellence awardWest Virginiasmoke alarmFive Star ratingdietitianNational Kidney MonthOrangeQIRN3rheumatologyNew JerseyimmunizationRenal Center of TrentonDenton police departmentDiane McGinnisRenal Center of Succasunnapermanent accessdialysisRenal Center of Port ArthurTuition reimbursementWinter Storm JonasSaint Barnabas Medical CenterSouthlake InfusionCertified Registered Nurse InfusionvideoPatient Satisfaction SurveyZ Constructors40th anniversaryretirementMary BowlesFire Prevention WeekDr. Parkeroral hygieneacute dialysisWorld Health DayPinnacle awardRenal Center of HamiltonCMSSavor the Flavor of Eating RightDr. George AronoffAmerican Society of NephrologyNational Kidney FoundationDOPPSWorld Kidney DayRV TLCSocial WorkerAmerican Diabetes AssociationNorth DentonDo's and Don'ts when interviewingRenal Center of CarrolltonRV DifferenceFlower MoundMother's DaySpirit AwardCarrolltonNational MS SocietyInfusion Center of DenverAuthentidateNKF walknew dialysis facilitytelehealth servicesCRNIplasmapheresisSouthlake, TXTake Your Dog to Work DayRenal Center of MorristownChoose My PlateRVCareRV Quality ProgramrecipeFitibtPinterestAccel Rehab hospitalNKFRV KidneyCAREEmployee AppreciationPaulding Phelps AwardPioneer awardANNADallasRenal Center of Bayonne#GoRedacquisitionInfusion nurseKindergartenpot de cremeYear in ReviewRugged ManiacFrosty the Snowmanperitoneal dialysisback to schoolflu shotflu vaccineElanderia RoweRenal Center of OrangeInternshiptravelNaveena ReddNederlandAnnual Dialysis Conferenceremote patient monitoringMultiple Sclerosis Societythe Action Centerhome dialysisCitizenship DayGlass of waterInternJCAHO accreditationwrestlingState Legislaturedialysis patient exerciseTracy MooreFitbitLobby DayWalk to Cure Arthritisconstructiondialysis treatmentDr. Stuart KassanBlizzard 2016RASKAL awardacute nurseBioMedmiss dialysisGo Red for WomencupcakeCMS rating systemBonfils blood donationDr. AronoffWorld Kidney MonthStrokemeningiomaapheresisbubble soccercookbookdental carePlanoopen houseNRAACosta VidaProteindialysis centerMPP InfusionCenters for Medicare and Medicaid ServiceshalitosisArthritis FoundationDum Dumstraveling on dialysisRenal Center of SomervilleRenal Center of North DentonPort ArthurRVMLifeOrange, TXnephronNew JerseAmerican College of RheumatologyHome Kidney CareSpring Clinical MeetingChildren's HospitalRV CAREdogsTexas Renal VenturesOfficer Orlando HInajosaInfusionRedesign American FlagToledo Bend ReservoirThe Hillsgum diseaseMichelle WeinraubKidney cookbookBone and Joint ExpoexercisePositively ProteinAvalon at Edgewaterkidney disease exerciseAmerican Heart AssociationBest Place to WorkNational Nutrition MonthRVM Kidney CareRenal Center of Planopatient newsletterNaveena ReddyKidney Life Dialysis Center10th anniversaryRV WellnessNew York YankeesCouncil of Nephrology Social WorkersSoutheast floodingHuman ResourcesKidney WeekgraduatesInformative InfuserANNA conferencehome hemodialysisAmerican Nephrology Nurses' AssociationJavier RodriguezKidney walkInterviewNorth Texas AcuteRenal Adventureswork anniversaryHeart DiseaseNephrology News


Aronoff's Point Of View: CMS rating system is flawed

Feb 05, 2015

Dr.-George-Aronoff.jpgThis month the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) added a Five-Star Quality Rating System to the Medicare Dialysis Facility Compare (DFC) website. The new rating system has been severely criticized by dialysis providers and patient advocacy groups. DFC was originally launched in 2001 to help consumers, their families, and caregivers compare dialysis units more easily. DFC provides general information about dialysis clinics, best clinical practices, hospitalizations and deaths. Unfortunately, DFC has not been as useful as it was originally hoped. Studies of DFC indicate that many patients and their families find it difficult to understand the descriptions of quality measures on the main web pages. I have been told that the DFC website is accessed more often by dialysis providers than dialysis patients.

Developing a five-star rating system to help Medicare beneficiaries make more informed choices about their dialysis care is a good idea. Many of us use similar ratings to choose restaurants, hotels, and even consumer products. Rating systems provide useful information when they accurately report information about those factors that are most important to our decisions about a product. For example, we expect that a five-star restaurant would have food that tastes better than a three-star restaurant and that the service at a five-star restaurant would be excellent.

Major criticisms of CMS's five-star dialysis unit rating system focus on whether CMS is accurately measuring factors that are important to dialysis patients and reporting them fairly. CMS has chosen to use data that were collected for far different purposes than to compare the quality of care among dialysis clinics. Many of these measures have little impact on patients' lives or their experience of care in a dialysis clinic. In addition, CMS has used very complicated methods to analyze the information making it almost impossible for individual clinics or patients to understand that there may be no real difference between a three-star dialysis unit and a five-star dialysis unit or even a one-star unit. Similar criticism has been leveled at other CMS five-star rating systems and has limited their usefulness to beneficiaries.

With all these flaws, I would still congratulate five-star units. They probably are doing something right. At the same time, I would encourage one- and two-star units to try to understand how the data that CMS used might have fallen short and how they might improve their patients' care and dialysis experience. A dialysis unit rating system could be helpful to our patients and their families. It is disappointing that CMS didn't take the opportunity to get this right.

Dr. George Aronoff is the Chief Medical Officer at Renal Ventures Management.  Dr. Aronoff comes from the University of Louisville School of Medicine, where he served as the Chief of the Nephrology Division for 23 years and as the Vice Chair of Medicine for Clinical Affairs. He currently holds the position of Professor of Medicine and Pharmacology there. Dr. Aronoff has 30 years of experience in designing and performing clinical research in hemodialysis, peritoneal dialysis, transplant and CKD patients.

- Read Dr. Aronoff's thoughts about how the CMS rating system can be improved

Category: Blogs